When you are looking for a high-quality mattress, you absolutely need to consider both the Saatva mattress and the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress. After all, they include coil-on-coil builds and only use the high-end materials. However, which one is the best for you? Which one suits best your needs.
Let’s check out each one of the mattresses in detail and then make the final comparison. Luckily, this will help you decide on the best mattress for you.
#1: Saatva Mattress:
Click to Check Price on Amazon
* Construction:
The Saatva mattress is a coil-on-coil innerspring mattress. This combination allows the Saatva mattress to include a coil total count of 1,300 which is really amazing. This factor alone will allow the Saatva mattress to be comfortable, supportive, and durable.
Take a look at the top mattresses on the market.
The Saatva mattress is 14.5 inches high and it includes 5 different layers:
– The top layer, which is a pillow top cover, is made of an organic cotton. This material ensures the breathability of the mattress as well as it is also extremely soft. In addition, the add of the euro-style pillow top just gives a luxurious look and an extra softness and comfort to the cover. These Euro-style pillow toppers are built into the mattress cover instead of sewn down on top of the mattress. In terms of aesthetics, it is the perfect combination of traditional and modern design.
– The second layer is made of memory foam and its main goal is to provide you with a good lumbar support. Even though this is a thin layer, it is able to provide you a good support.
– The third layer is made of foam encased contour coils. This is the layer responsible for the feel and comfort of the entire mattress. One of the best things about this layer is that it is built form 884 individually wrapped coils. This allows the motion transfer to be minimal meaning that you can keep tossing and turning the entire night without waking up the person next to you. In addition, it also helps improve the body contouring adding an extra support and comfort.
– The bottom layer, or the foundation layer, which is 7 inches high, is made of high-profile hour glass coils. It is made using the traditional hourglass shaped steel coils totaling 416 in the Queen size.
– The edge layers are made of a support foam and they come along the edges of the Saatva mattress to increase the durability of the mattress as well as to improve the edge support.
* Firmness:
The Saatva mattress is actually available in 3 different firmness levels. So, you can actually suit the one that best fits you. The different firmness levels include:
– The Soft mattress, where we have the Saatva mattress at a 3 out of 10;
– The Medium mattress, where we have the Saatva mattress at a 6 out of 10;
– The Firm mattress, where we have the Saatva mattress at an 8 out of 10.
* Comfort:
One of the best things about the Saatva mattress is the bounce. It’s really amazing how the company managed to create such a bounce using an innerspring mattress. It allows you to easily change positions during the night and since the motion transfer is minimal, you won’t even bother your partner.
Another unique feature of the Saatva mattress is that it includes high-quality materials only- They made sure to include several organic and other healthy materials from the 100% organic cotton cover to the use of the natural thistle as a fire retardant instead of the traditional chemicals, among others.
Discover the top mattresses for stomach sleepers.
* Trials And Warranties:
The Saatva mattress comes with a better manufacturer warranty than other top mattresses. You will have a 15-year warranty. In addition, they also allow you to have a trial period of 120 days which is also more than other top mattresses on the market.
#2: Simmons Beautyrest Black Mattress
Click to Check Price on Amazon
Since there are many different Simmons Beautyrest Black mattresses, we decided to use the one that is more similar to the Saatva mattress – the Black Katarina Luxury Firm Pillow Top Mattress model.
* Construction:
The Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress us a luxurious mattress that can be considered a hybrid mattress. The truth is that instead of using only foam or only coils, the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress makes the perfect combination of using both. And the result is absolutely amazing.
The Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is 15.5 inches tall and includes 4 different layers besides the cover:
– The cover is made of a soft modal yarn fabric. In addition, it also contains Tencel, which is a material known for its high breathability as well as for being able to maintain the mattress surface cool. Even though the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress doesn’t include a full pillow topper, it does include several different layers that give the same sense and feel of the Saatva mattress. The cover is made with a 1 inch of soft foam and 0.75 inches of gel foam. Aesthetically speaking, the cover is a traditional cover with some small black diamonds along the mattress to give it a sense of uniqueness.
– The top layer, which is 1 inch high, is made of Aircool memory foam.
– The second layer, which is also 1 inch high, is made of Micro Diamond Infused Aircool memory foam.
– The third layer, which is only 0.5 inches, is made of a dynamic response memory foam.
– The fourth layer, which is 1.5 inches high, is made of comfort contour coils that are individually wrapped.
– The bottom layer, which is 11.5 inches high, is made of individually wrapped coils that are also known as Simmons Beautyrest’ Verifoam advanced pocketed coil system. You can count on 850 individual coils in the Queen size and they act as a deep compression support for sleepers who are heavier. One of the things that this layer also includes is a mini o.5 inches layer made of foam. This is more than enough to absorb and reduce motion transfer.
* Firmness:
Just like the Saatva mattress, the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is also available in different firmness levels. You can find Simmons Beautyrest Black mattresses ranging between 3 and 9 out of 10 on the firmness scale.
In the case of the Black Katarina Luxury Firm Pillow Top Mattress, we believe that it is a 6 out of 10 (with 10 referring to the firmest mattresses).
* Comfort:
One of the things that is pretty evident in the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is the huge amount of different layers used. This reveals the effort of the brand to build a good hybrid mattress that is able to provide you with comfort, support, and durability.
One of the things that we particularly like about the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is the fact that while the mattress provides you with an impressive support, a great feel, and a good body contouring, you can still expect not to sink into the mattress as it is something rather common when we are talking about memory foam mattresses.
Both the bounce as well as the cooling are just as good on the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress as on the Saatva mattress.
* Trials And Warranties:
The Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress comes with a regular 10-year warranty from the manufacturer and you will also be entitled to 100 days of trial period.
Saatva Vs. Simmons Beautyrest Black Mattress Conclusion
As you saw through the description of each one of the mattresses, even though they are very similar in some aspects, they also present several and noticeable differences.
The differences between the Saatva mattress and the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress are numerous. They start with the layers amount and materials used, the coil count that is very superior in the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress, the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is also higher than the Saatva mattress, the cover, and even the warranty and trial periods are different, with Saatva coming out as the winner. However, it’s also important to state that the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is a lot more expensive than the Saatva mattress.
So, which one is better for you? Should you choose the Saatva mattress or the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress?
In our opinion, the Saatva is the winner. We really like the Euro-style pillow top that it features in addition to all the organic and green materials they have decided to use. Ultimately, the price is another heavy reason. After all, the Saatva is a lot more affordable than the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress.
Even though we believe that the Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress is comfortable and supportive, includes high-quality materials, is durable, among so many other things, the price may be a little too much.
